The popular play-by-email (PBEM) site Axis and Allies Members Club (which I have no affiliation with and which I hadn't logged onto in years until I did some research for this post) keeps statistics on the games played by its members. I'll attempt to provide hard evidence and quantify this advantage. Others have explained why the Axis have a significant disadvantage in the 2nd Edition rules.
You make attacks against you prohibitively expensive, but you are free to send waves of infantry into Germany if you see any weakness there.Īnswering the question with AAMC bid statistics Early in the game, the UK is mostly a punching bag.Īs Russia, you can prevent an early assault by massing infantry on you borders, especially against Germany. If you can keep a UK fleet alive through the early phases of the game, you can effectively pin Germany down in Europe build up major industry in India.
UK, US & Russia are all good late game countries. A safer approach is to go for Africa & have Japan invade Asia You have to have plenty of luck on your side. If you can hold it at the beginning of your turn, the game is basically over. lets just say a bunker suicide might not sound so bad after all.Ī risky strategy has Germany taking Leningrad early. If you haven't wiped out the British fleet early in the game and made solid progress into Africa by the time the Americans start showing up, well. If you like playing the Axis side, I would rank Germany as having a small advantage on the first turn, but it erodes quickly. So from that perspective, the US & UK might be considered 'best countries', if there is such a thing. Overall, A&A is an economic game & the Allies have the advantage. I would say Russia is the best in terms of fun to play, but it's not the strongest. I havn't played this game in years, but I always like playing Russia. I tried finding some web site specifically discussing stats on various countries, but came up empty, so you'll have to settle for qualitative data from me at least. Statistically, I think the Axis get the short end.